Comments on 'Maximally permissive supervisor synthesis based on a new constraint transformation method'

Luo et al. proposed a new method to design the maximally permissive and efficient supervisor for enforcing linear constraints on an ordinary Petri net with uncontrollable transitions. In order to develop this method, Theorem 3 is given. It is clamed that “a linear constraint can be equivalently transformed at an uncontrollable transition into a disjunction of weakly admissible ones.” However, this result is erroneous. In this correspondence paper, a counterexample contradicting it is presented.